Published October 9, 1999
Joe Vargo
The Press-Enterprise
Carolina Ayala admitted Friday that a night spent partying contributed to her daughter's death.
While Ayala slumbered in her bed after celebrating with friends,
15-month-old Krystal Dominguez died strapped in a car seat as
temperatures rose to nearly 150 degrees. Ayala, 21, pleaded guilty to felony child endangerment and was
immediately sentenced to six years in state prison. Dressed in a blue jail jumpsuit and shackled hand and foot, she
sobbed quietly throughout her court appearance. Ayala spoke only to answer "guilty" when Superior Court Judge
Gordon R. Burkhart asked whether she "willfully and unlawfully"
endangered Krystal, who died of heat stroke. Prosecutors and the defense attorney said the punishment fit the
crime. Police discovered no evidence that Ayala was under the influence
of drugs when she left Krystal in the driveway of her mother's home
on June 26, said Deputy District Attorney Kennis Clark. "There was real remorse, she confessed almost immediately," Clark
said of Ayala's state of mind. "But there was neglect as well. Most
felony child endangerment cases don't result because of intent. She
had care and custody of the child . It's tragic because she made bad
choices." The night before her daughter died, Ayala and a friend went to a
party, leaving Krystal with the friend's mother. The two women were
at the party until almost dawn and Ayala went to her friend's home
to sleep, only to be told a couple of hours later that she and her
daughter had to leave. A family emergency had developed at the
sitter's home, Clark said. Either Ayala or someone else strapped Krystal into her child
seat, Clark said. Ayala drove the short distance to her family's
home on Promenade Bordeaux, forgetting that her daughter remained
in the back seat. By the time she woke up again at 11:15 a.m. and
found Krystal in the car , it was too late. Defense attorney Julie Scalisi said Ayala will live knowing that
she contributed to her daughter's death . In addition to the six
year-sentence imposed Friday, Ayala could also face up to five
additional years in jail for violating her parole from a previous
federal drug conviction. A second conviction is a parole violation. "This is not the real punishment," Scalisi said after the
sentencing. "She is wracked with grief and guilt. It's just a
tragedy." Ayala's brother finds little solace in the sentence.
Interviewed Friday, he said his sister should have taken better
care of her daughter and finds it hard to forgive her. While other
family members have visited Ayala in jail, he said he cannot yet
face his sister. "When people become adults, they have to make adult decisions,"
said Gustavo Ayala, 17, a Temecula Valley High School student. "She
wanted to still be a child . If six years fits the crime, then I'm
satisfied. She's going to be in prison thinking about what she did." Gustavo Ayala keeps his niece's pink blanket on his bed. Whenever he looks at her handprint, left in wet cement from a
remodeling job at the family's home, he thinks of Krystal. He
remembers how she bounded toward him when he came home from school each day, how she clamped her arms around his leg. He remembers how
she came to his room and danced whenever she heard him listening to
music. "Every time I think of the good memories," he said, "the bad
memories come. Then I sit in my room and cry." Defense attorney Scalisi said Carolina Ayala was working to
rebuild her life following the drug conviction. Ayala knew "she had made some bad decisions" earlier in her life
but was "a loving and devoted mom who was doing everything right"
in rearing her child , Scalisi said. "That's what makes this death all the more tragic," Scalisi said.